01-15-2012 09:14 PM - edited 01-15-2012 09:19 PM
Welcome to the group, Stephen.
Well... it's hard to judge the best saw blade for you until we get some insight into what brand/model table saw you have that's going to drive the blade.
01-15-2012 09:31 PM - edited 01-15-2012 09:32 PM
Matt's point is the saw's horsepower required to turn a 6" versus an 8" stacked dado set under load.
Most 6" sets will do all you want to on a table saw. Radial Arm Saws may require an 8" set because of the fence arrangement.
I have a JET 1.5 horsepower Contractor's table saw and I use a 6" Forrest Dado King stacked set with great results. Maybe 1.5 HP might not be proper for an 8" set.
A warm welcome to the WOOD Forums..
01-16-2012 12:57 AM
I still use Craftsman wobble dado set that gives me fine and flat cuts.
My TS engine runs on one horse, too.Depending on your budget and prefferences... some like the more expensive ones due to name brand.
01-16-2012 06:26 AM
What Matt said - depends on the saw.
I have a 5 hp cabinet saw. I can run an 8" dado up to full cutting width without any trouble.
That might not be the case with a 1.5 hp or less saw.
Look at the "mechanics" - you are rotating a lot of mass at a high speed. This requires energy. A 6" dado has less mass than an 8" dado - therefore it requires less energy (hp) to rotate the dado. For Tony's wobble dado, you are only talking about two blades rather than a "stack: of blades - that requires less hp to rotate the blades at speed.
01-16-2012 07:09 AM
Not only would you want to consider the strain of an 8" vs a 6", but why would you need an 8"? I was in the same situation as you when I was buying a stacked dado. Did all my research, and while my 1hp probably could've turned it, there was no sense in spending the extra money for the 8".
If you look around the forums, you'll see a lot of guys will run thin-kerf blades just to minimize any undue stress on our motors. So why add the weight of the 8" dado if you don't need it.
Deepest dado I've ever cut was a bit over 1/2" deep so I still had plenty of blade to go if I ever needed to go deeper.
Went with a Freud 6" and have been very satisfied with it. I take the time to set it up before I even think about dropping a bit into the router table. It's just easier and makes a cleaner cut...for me.
01-16-2012 07:31 AM
Some points to ponder in a stacked dado set:
These are generic observations and not intended to favor one size over another.
If your need is not immediate, the following video may be of interest in the decision process:
WOOD Online has a very respectable library of free videos for your education and enjoyment in the pursuit of learning more about the craft of woodworking.
There are two channels you can look at for specific subjects:
The first is WOODCuts.
This is the site to go for “house” videos that WOOD magazine has produced for its site visitors. Although these may have commercials in them, and thus have a bit of a loading wait, they are still solid blocks of good to know information professionally shot and edited, with clear and concise demonstrations.
The second resource for videos is WOODTube.
These are user submitted videos usually shot by woodworkers who wish to visually share tips, tricks, and techniques they feel are worth passing on. This site has a search engine so you can get more specific in your need to know area.
Don't ask advice on federal firearms law from people on the internet unless you like jail food.
- Beachside Hank, WOOD Online Video Host
01-16-2012 07:34 AM
I'm going to take a different viewpoint. The main horsepower concern isn't 6" vs 8"... simply how deep and wide of wood you're cutting in 1 pass. So then the issue to me would be 8" has more "tip speed" thereby a smoother cut... although that can be adjusted also by how fast you feed it through. So I'd guess since you can make multiple passes, an 8" would be able to cut 1" deeper than a 6"... if you ever needed it too????
01-16-2012 08:17 AM
When I bought my Freud Super Dado set a few years back, I was looking for a 6" set, since my saw is only 1 3/4 HP. I ended up buying the 8" set, as that is the only one they had left in stock. I have had no problems with the saw being under powered, because I never cut deeper than 1/2 to 5/8 inch. The main thing is, don't force, let the saw work as it should. I love my set.
01-16-2012 09:00 AM
I believe mine only has one blade.
I also think that any saw, from 1 HP and up, can run any dao set.
The cuts of around 3/8 can be done quite cleanly. Depending on person usage, though.
The material should not be forced, rather let the blade do the work and user should only guide the work.
Aftwer all, how deep of a cut one needs?!
Seldom one will need more than 1/2 inch deep.